I wrote this for my English class
Jean-Jacques Rousseau believed people are inherently good-natured, caring, and inquisitive creatures. He felt that our education systems taught children to become useful to society, but that they stifled true learning and the natural methods of enlightenment. Rousseau’s writings and thoughts have influenced thousands of people but have not had a considerable impact upon the way education is run in America. America’s education system is the very kind of systematic, institutionalized sort of anti-learning organization Rousseau was writing about in the eighteenth century.
Education has become a stifling system of monotonous and tedious routines executed over and over again and repeated until one has given up on their absurdity or either endured the anathema right up until they are given their hard earned right to be come over-qualified and under-paid. A truly fantastic system for encouraging learning! From personal experience, I know that we are taught how to glean facts from selected readings and learn what the state has decided is prudent for our societal development, we are not taught how to formulate our own ideas, nor are we stressed the importance of self education. The autodidactic learner died with our founding fathers. Today we are a nation of ignorant, illiterate people dependent upon others to tell us what to believe, and this is the result of years and years of an educational system that rivals the creativity of, well….insert inanimate object here.
Rousseau suggested a form of education that nurtured to children’s natural tendencies to explore and ask questions. He felt that forcing them to sit still in rows and be quiet while they were spoken to was against their already reliably probing personalities. This is very true, people should not abhor learning, but because of the way in which we are exposed to ‘learning’ most people do. I have learned so much more on my own accord than I have ever learned in a classroom, it makes me furious. By the time I was in high school I was pointing out spelling and other grammatical errors in my English teachers’ lessons. Go America.
Of course, there are teachers who do their best to give their students an experience the likes of which would make Rousseau proud, but their efforts are limited by the impositions of the state. Impositions which are made perhaps with the best of intentions, perhaps not, but either way, their effects have wreaked havoc upon the cumulative intelligence of the world’s people and their posterity. Questioning the status quo has always been the impetus behind the most revolutionary changes of society. Sadly, I believe there are a dwindling number of people who challenge the effectiveness and motives behind popular education.
If one were to ask ten ambitious academics at any prestigious school in the country why they have applied themselves so assiduously to their work, I would wager that nine of them would tell you “so I can get a good job”. That is perhaps the root of our problem, people dedicate themselves to earning good grades (whatever the hell those represent) in order to get into a respected and venerable college, and once there they slave over their work like passionless robots until they have powered through years of toil and torture. Upon graduation they use their degree to finally procure for themselves a job with a respectable salary, or perhaps they go to law school, or medical school, of course for fiscal reasons once more. It is love of money, not learning that propels the ‘exemplary’ student forward, it is not honorable perseverance nor demonstration of work ethic, it is vanity.
Albert Einstein was a poor student, and a tremendous learner, as was Rousseau and countless other writers and artists. Education is another extension of the superfluous appendages hanging from the dead tree of society. There is no truth in it, there is no progress, there is regress, and for the thinking, impassioned individual of the mind there is a long arduous struggle against an unseen entity.

7 comments:
My dear son,how is it that at the ripe old age of 19 you can be so cynical? Though I am by no means, a brainiac, I certainly did well in school, albeit, high school was in fact the extent of my education. For as many people who may feel the way you do, about education, there are as many, or more who vehemently disagree. In education, as in most things, I believe, you get out of it, what you put into it. There are millions who worked their tushies off in school, learning, and earning good marks, and then furthering their educations so that they could achieve financial independence, and yes, many are happy with those choices. It has been my experience, that most would say that their true educations began when they left school, and entered the work place and/or "real world" as it is so often called. And you too, my handsome son, as bright as you are, you still have much to learn!!! And I love you ever so much!!!
Mama
My comment would have to be, that not all people are driven to learn by the desire to earn a lot of money. For a short period of time in high school, I wanted to become a lawyer, in part because I thought I could make a lot of money. But after really thinking about it, I knew I did not want to go to school for the amount that occupation would require. And I thought that I would enjoy doing hair more, even if I made less money. So now today, I still do hair, and working part time, make hardly any money, but I am still driven everyday to learn new things, in my work environment, and other aspects of my life.
I think when it comes to education everyone is different. And I do agree with mom, that some of your best learning begins once you leave school and enter the next phase of your life. Book smart, and street smart are two very different things too.
Jake said...
From my personal experience, I took a two year class on how to formulate my own ideas in regard to my profession. It is also part of my job to further my education everyday.
Education is not always someone telling you what you should believe. sometimes there is only one right answer.
I suspect you are not in a situation to understand suffering through a boring econ class, trying to get an A, to be admitted into pharmacy school. You have it pretty good.
Those 9 out of 10 are not just looking for jobs or for money. They want a career in something they love, and are truly interested in. It's also nice when that career pays the countless bills you are not yet aware of.
Genny,
learning has nothing to do with making money, i never said that people were driven to learn by the desire to earn a lot of money. i said people are driven to earn good grades because of their desire for money. Learning as i know it and believe in it, is separate from what i have been exposed to in school, and that's just my opinion, it's not incontrovertible. everyone is inherently different but i have observed a lot of people (definitely the majority) while i was in school and nearly everyone i knew had better grades than me, but they didn't care for learning, and frankly they didn't know how to learn, they only knew how to regurgitate facts because that is what they have been taught.
Jake,
my observations, and the prompt for the assignment were pertaining more to primary education. (elementary, middle, and high school) Admittedly, there are people who have earned their degrees and truly love what they do, and those are not the people i was writing about, i suppose that is the danger in generalizing, especially with rhetoric. i have, however, endured a boring econ class (though notably not to get into pharmacy school) to get into college. but maybe guys like you are the 10 percent, i mean i did acknowledge that not everyone who aspires to higher education is doing it only for money, even if i might have exaggerated the percentage.
Mom,
Maybe i am a cynic, i don't know. i just don't like our public education system. Of course you get out of it what you put into it, because that is the way it is designed, and im not saying that's backwards or anything. I didnt expect any medals for slacking off in high school, and i didn't deserve any. Rousseau's idea, and my own, for education, is to make it more real, like this "real world" you mentioned. It should be less contrived, less regulated, and more authentic. I don't deny that i have much to learn, i will always have much to learn, just like you will and anyone else for that matter. We all have much to learn.
I love you too!!!!!!
Drew
Those things you mention about school, are precisely the reason I think you will be a fabulous teacher. You will relate to students in a way that many teachers could, or would not.
Keep on plugging along at school, and I assure you, one day, you will be so glad for it.
G'night.
Mama
Post a Comment